The Texas Longhorns’ 28-14 loss to Ohio State in the Cotton Bowl has ignited a firestorm of criticism directed at head coach Steve Sarkisian. Fans, analysts, and former players have all weighed in, with many questioning his play-calling, game management, and decision-making in critical moments.
For a Texas team that had high hopes of finishing the season on a strong note, the defeat was not just disappointing—it was frustrating. The loss has raised concerns about whether Sarkisian is the right coach to lead the Longhorns into their transition to the SEC.
The Game That Broke Texas Fans
The Cotton Bowl was a chance for Texas to prove itself against one of the nation’s premier programs. Coming off a solid season, the Longhorns were eager to make a statement. Instead, the game exposed some major weaknesses—both in execution and coaching strategy.
One of the most controversial moments came late in the fourth quarter. Texas, trailing 21-14, had the ball inside the Ohio State 5-yard line with a chance to tie the game. Fans were confident that Texas would punch it in and keep their hopes alive.
Instead, what followed was a disastrous sequence of play calls:
- First Down: Texas ran straight up the middle, gaining little to no yardage.
- Second Down: Sarkisian called a shotgun toss play, which was immediately blown up for a big loss.
- Third Down: A hurried pass attempt fell incomplete.
- Fourth Down: Quinn Ewers was strip-sacked, and Ohio State returned the fumble for a touchdown, sealing the game.
It was a brutal way to lose, and Texas fans immediately turned their frustration toward Sarkisian.
Fans Demand Answers
Following the game, Texas fans flooded social media with criticism. Many pointed out that Sarkisian’s red-zone play-calling has been a recurring issue. Others questioned why backup quarterback Arch Manning—who is known for his mobility—was not used in certain situations.
Some of the common complaints from fans included:
- “Why are we running a toss play at the 2-yard line?”
- “Sarkisian is a great recruiter, but his in-game coaching is a disaster.”
- “We’re never going to win big games if we can’t finish drives.”
- “Arch Manning should have been in there on that goal-line series.”
The frustration is understandable. Texas fans have endured over a decade of mediocrity since the Mack Brown era, and while Sarkisian has improved the program, moments like these raise doubts about his ability to win at the highest level.
Sarkisian Defends His Decisions
In his post-game press conference, Sarkisian acknowledged the frustration but defended his decisions.
“Obviously, in hindsight, we wish we had executed better,” he said. “We felt like we had a play that would work, but Ohio State made a great defensive play. That’s football.”
When asked about the decision not to use Arch Manning, Sarkisian said, “We believe in Quinn Ewers, and we didn’t feel like a quarterback change was necessary at that point.”
While some fans appreciated Sarkisian taking responsibility, many were not satisfied with his explanations.
What This Loss Means for Sarkisian’s Future
While Sarkisian is not in danger of losing his job, this loss has placed more pressure on him heading into 2024. Texas will be moving to the SEC next season, and the competition will only get tougher.
Here are some key challenges he faces:
1. Fixing Red Zone Play-Calling
This has been an issue all season, and it must be addressed if Texas wants to compete in the SEC. The Longhorns left too many points on the field in 2023, and Sarkisian must find better ways to finish drives.
2. Quarterback Controversy?
With Ewers likely heading to the NFL Draft, Arch Manning is expected to take over as the starter. If Manning struggles, the criticism of Sarkisian will only grow louder.
3. Proving He Can Win Big Games
Sarkisian has yet to deliver a true signature win at Texas. Beating Alabama early in the season was impressive, but losses like this one continue to raise doubts about whether he can lead Texas to a championship.
4. Recruiting vs. Coaching
There is no doubt that Sarkisian is an elite recruiter, but fans are beginning to wonder if his coaching is holding the team back. If Texas continues to underperform in big games, the pressure to make a change could intensify.
Looking Ahead to the SEC
The Cotton Bowl loss was disappointing, but the real test for Sarkisian begins in 2024. Texas will be entering the toughest conference in college football, where every game will be a battle.
If Sarkisian can learn from his mistakes and make the necessary adjustments, Texas still has the talent to be a contender. However, if the same issues persist, the fan base’s patience will wear thin.
For now, Sarkisian remains the coach of the Longhorns, but the clock is ticking. If Texas continues to come up short in big games, fans may start calling for a change.
One thing is certain: The 2024 season will define Steve Sarkisian’s legacy at Texas.