Hockey rivalries have always been intense, but emotions boiled over during a recent matchup between the Colorado Avalanche and Dallas Stars. A controversial play by Stars captain Jamie Benn on Avalanche superstar Cale Makar has left fans and analysts alike debating the limits of physicality in the NHL. For Avalanche fans, however, there’s little debate: Benn’s move was dirty, deliberate, and completely unacceptable.
The incident, which occurred in the second period of a heated contest, has sparked outrage across social media and reignited long-standing tensions between the two teams. With Makar’s health potentially compromised and Benn’s reputation as an agitator under scrutiny, this moment may have lasting implications for both franchises.
The Play: Benn’s Controversial Hit
The play in question took place during a high-stakes game that was already charged with playoff intensity. With the Avalanche leading 3-2 midway through the second period, Makar carried the puck through the neutral zone, looking to generate offense. Benn, who was trailing the play, delivered what many are calling a reckless and unnecessary hit to Makar, blindsiding him near the boards.
Makar immediately went down, clutching his shoulder and grimacing in pain. The hit appeared to target an unprotected area, with Benn’s shoulder making direct contact with Makar’s upper body. While no penalty was called on the play, replays showed the hit was dangerously close to the head—a violation that the NHL has cracked down on in recent years.
Avalanche Fans React
The reaction from Avalanche fans was swift and furious. Social media platforms lit up with posts condemning Benn’s actions, with many calling for a suspension or fine. For a fanbase that has seen its fair share of injuries to key players, the possibility of losing Makar—arguably the team’s most important player—was infuriating.
“This wasn’t hockey. This was an intentional attempt to injure one of the league’s best players,” one fan tweeted. Another wrote, “Jamie Benn has always been a dirty player, and tonight just proved it again. The league needs to take action before someone gets seriously hurt.”
The hashtag #ProtectMakar began trending on Twitter as Avalanche fans rallied to demand accountability from both Benn and the NHL’s Department of Player Safety.
The Importance of Cale Makar
To understand the level of outrage from Avalanche fans, one must consider Makar’s significance to the team. Widely regarded as one of the best defensemen in the NHL, Makar is a game-changer on both ends of the ice. His ability to skate, pass, and score has redefined the role of a modern defenseman, earning him accolades like the Norris Trophy and Conn Smythe Trophy at just 24 years old.
Makar’s presence is essential to the Avalanche’s success. Not only does he anchor the team’s defensive efforts, but he also drives offense, often leading rushes and quarterbacking the power play. Losing him to an injury, especially one caused by what many see as a dirty play, would be devastating for Colorado’s playoff hopes.
Jamie Benn’s Reputation
While Benn is undeniably a talented player and leader for the Stars, his reputation as a physical and sometimes controversial player has followed him throughout his career. Known for playing on the edge, Benn has been involved in several incidents that have drawn criticism from fans and players alike.
This latest play only adds fuel to the fire, with many accusing Benn of targeting Makar intentionally. While Benn has defenders who argue that his physical style is part of what makes him an effective player, incidents like this one make it harder to dismiss the perception that he crosses the line too often.
The NHL’s Response
One of the biggest points of contention among Avalanche fans is the lack of immediate action from the referees. No penalty was called on Benn for the hit, leaving many to question the officiating. In a league that has emphasized player safety in recent years, particularly when it comes to hits targeting the head, the absence of a penalty felt like a glaring oversight.
The NHL’s Department of Player Safety is now under pressure to review the play and determine if supplemental discipline is warranted. Avalanche fans are demanding at least a suspension, arguing that the league needs to send a clear message that such hits have no place in the game.
However, critics of the NHL’s disciplinary system have pointed out its inconsistency. While some players receive harsh penalties for borderline plays, others seem to escape unscathed. The outcome of this case could have significant implications for how the league handles similar incidents in the future.
The Rivalry Between the Avalanche and Stars
The bad blood between the Avalanche and Stars adds another layer of intensity to this controversy. As two of the top teams in the Western Conference, the rivalry has grown in recent years, fueled by playoff matchups and physical, high-stakes games.
For Avalanche fans, Benn’s hit is just the latest example of what they see as the Stars’ overly aggressive tactics. Stars fans, meanwhile, have defended their captain, arguing that the Avalanche are exaggerating the severity of the play.
This incident is likely to intensify the rivalry further, setting the stage for even more heated contests in the future.
The Broader Issue of Player Safety
Benn’s hit on Makar also raises broader questions about player safety in the NHL. Despite the league’s efforts to crack down on dangerous hits, incidents like this one continue to occur. For many, the lack of a penalty on the ice highlights the ongoing challenges of enforcing rules designed to protect players.
The NHL has introduced measures like fines and suspensions to deter dangerous plays, but critics argue that these penalties are often inconsistent or insufficient. If Benn escapes significant discipline for this hit, it could reignite debates about whether the league is doing enough to prioritize player safety.
The Avalanche’s Next Steps
For the Avalanche, the immediate concern is Makar’s health. While initial reports suggest he avoided a serious injury, the team will likely monitor him closely in the coming days. Losing Makar for any length of time would be a significant blow, particularly as the team fights for playoff positioning.
In the longer term, the Avalanche may use this incident as motivation. Teams often rally around moments of adversity, and the anger over Benn’s hit could fuel the Avalanche’s performance in future games.
Jamie Benn’s Perspective
While Benn has not yet publicly addressed the hit, it’s likely that he will face questions about his intentions. Some players in similar situations have argued that their actions were unintentional or part of the natural flow of the game. Whether Benn takes this approach or acknowledges fault remains to be seen.
Regardless of his response, Benn’s reputation will likely take another hit, particularly among Avalanche fans.
Fans Demand Accountability
For Avalanche fans, the fallout from this incident isn’t just about one game or one player—it’s about the integrity of the sport. Many are calling on the NHL to take a stronger stance against dangerous plays, arguing that allowing such hits to go unpunished sets a dangerous precedent.
One fan summed up the sentiment on social media: “If the league doesn’t suspend Benn for this, they’re basically saying it’s open season on star players. It’s unacceptable.”
The Fallout
As the dust settles, the implications of Benn’s hit on Makar will continue to be felt. Whether through NHL discipline, heightened tensions in future matchups, or the broader conversation about player safety, this incident is unlikely to fade from memory anytime soon.
For now, Avalanche fans are left waiting—waiting for updates on Makar’s health, waiting for the league’s decision on discipline, and waiting for their next chance to face the Stars. One thing is certain: the rivalry between these two teams just got a lot more personal.
In a sport known for its intensity, moments like this remind us of the fine line between physicality and recklessness. For the Avalanche, the hope is that this controversy will serve as a rallying point rather than a setback. And for Jamie Benn, the scrutiny over this hit may follow him for the rest of his career.