Projected $119 million superstar called ‘better option’ for Mets than Pete Alonso

As the New York Mets prepare for another pivotal offseason, rumors and debates about the future of their roster continue to swirl. At the center of it all is Pete Alonso, the Mets’ slugging first baseman and fan favorite, whose contract situation has made him a focal point for trade speculation. While Alonso’s contributions to the team are undeniable, some analysts are pointing to a different player as a potentially better long-term option for the Mets.

That player is Matt Olson of the Atlanta Braves, projected to earn a staggering $119 million over the next five seasons. Analysts argue that Olson’s skill set, age, and consistency make him a stronger fit for the Mets’ future, particularly as they aim to build a sustainable contender. This comparison has sparked heated discussions among fans, analysts, and insiders about what the Mets should do with Alonso and whether Olson is truly the superior choice.

Pete Alonso: A Mets Icon

Since debuting with the Mets in 2019, Pete Alonso has been a cornerstone of the franchise. Known for his prodigious power and leadership on and off the field, Alonso has become one of the most feared hitters in Major League Baseball.

Alonso’s Career Highlights:

• 2019 National League Rookie of the Year: Set a rookie record with 53 home runs.
• 3-Time All-Star: Consistently ranks among MLB leaders in home runs and RBIs.
• Fan Favorite: Affectionately nicknamed “Polar Bear,” Alonso is beloved by Mets fans.

Concerns About Alonso’s Future:

1. Defensive Limitations: Critics argue that Alonso’s defensive skills at first base are below average, potentially limiting his overall value.
2. Contract Status: Alonso is set to become a free agent after the 2024 season, and re-signing him could require a massive financial commitment.
3. Offensive Consistency: While Alonso’s power is undeniable, some point to streaky performances as a concern.

Matt Olson: A Rising Superstar

Matt Olson, currently with the Atlanta Braves, has emerged as one of the most well-rounded first basemen in baseball. With a powerful bat and Gold Glove-caliber defense, Olson has become a key figure in the Braves’ sustained success.

Olson’s 2023 Season Stats:

• Home Runs: 54 (led MLB).
• RBIs: 139 (career high).
• On-Base Plus Slugging (OPS): .993.
• Defensive Metrics: Ranked among the top first basemen in defensive runs saved.

Why Analysts Prefer Olson:

1. Defensive Excellence: Olson’s elite defense at first base adds value beyond his offensive production.
2. Consistency: Olson has been one of the most reliable hitters in baseball, with fewer slumps than Alonso.
3. Age and Contract: Olson is under contract through 2029 on a team-friendly deal, providing cost certainty for the Braves.

The $119 Million Factor

Olson’s remaining contract, which guarantees him $119 million over the next five years, is seen as a bargain relative to his production. For comparison, Alonso could command a deal worth $200 million or more in free agency, raising questions about whether the Mets would be better off investing elsewhere.

Financial Considerations:

• Olson’s Deal: Locked in at an average annual value (AAV) of $23.8 million.
• Alonso’s Projected Deal: Could exceed $35 million AAV, depending on market demand.
• Budget Impact: Opting for a player like Olson would allow the Mets to allocate resources to other areas of need, such as starting pitching or bullpen depth.

Comparing the Two Players

While both Alonso and Olson are among the best first basemen in the game, their skill sets and profiles differ in ways that could influence the Mets’ decision-making.

Mets Fans React

The debate over Alonso versus Olson has sparked passionate reactions from Mets fans, who are divided on the best course of action.

Pro-Alonso Camp:

• “Alonso is the heart and soul of this team. You can’t just let him walk!”
• “He’s more than just a player—he’s a leader and a fan favorite.”

Pro-Olson Camp:

• “Olson’s all-around game makes him the better choice for a championship team.”
• “If Alonso’s asking price is too high, we should explore other options like Olson.”

Analysts Weigh In

Baseball analysts have also weighed in on the debate, offering insights into the strengths and weaknesses of both players.

Supporting Olson:

• “Olson’s defense and consistency give him an edge in overall value.”
• “The Mets need to think long-term. Olson’s contract is a steal compared to what Alonso might demand.”

Supporting Alonso:

• “Alonso is the face of the Mets. Losing him would be a huge blow to the team and its fanbase.”
• “There’s no guarantee Olson would replicate his success in New York.”

Potential Scenarios for the Mets

As the Mets weigh their options, several scenarios could play out regarding Alonso and their pursuit of a player like Olson:

1. Re-Sign Alonso: The Mets could offer Alonso a long-term extension, keeping their homegrown star in New York.
2. Trade Alonso: If Alonso’s contract demands are too high, the Mets could trade him for a package of prospects and pursue other options at first base.
3. Explore Free Agents: Instead of Olson, the Mets could target a different free-agent first baseman or focus on bolstering other areas of their roster.

Conclusion

The debate over Pete Alonso versus Matt Olson highlights the tough decisions the Mets face as they look to build a sustainable contender. While Alonso’s power and leadership have made him a fan favorite, Olson’s well-rounded game and affordable contract make him an appealing alternative.

Ultimately, the Mets’ decision will come down to their priorities: retaining a beloved franchise player or exploring options that might provide more value in the long term. As the offseason unfolds, all eyes will be on how the Mets navigate this critical juncture in their pursuit of a championship.