The world of college football is no stranger to controversy, especially when it comes to quarterback debates. The latest drama involves former Notre Dame quarterback Malik Zaire, who recently took a shot at Ohio State’s new quarterback, Will Howard. In a blunt and somewhat dismissive comment, Zaire compared Howard to Penn State’s Drew Allar, implying that the two quarterbacks were essentially the same player in different uniforms.
The remark immediately sparked debate among fans, analysts, and players, with many viewing it as an unnecessary dig at Howard. But was Zaire’s comment simply an honest assessment, or was it an outright disrespectful shot at the new Buckeye signal-caller? Let’s break down the situation, Howard’s journey to Ohio State, and what this means for the Buckeyes moving forward.
The Comment That Started It All
Malik Zaire, who played for Notre Dame from 2013 to 2016, made headlines when he tweeted,
“Will Howard is just Drew Allar in different color jerseys!!!!”
On the surface, this may not seem like a direct insult, but in the world of college football, comparisons carry weight. The implication here is that Howard isn’t anything special—just another big-bodied, strong-armed quarterback with no real distinction from other players at his position.
Why does this matter? Because both Howard and Allar have been the subject of intense scrutiny. Allar, despite being a highly-rated recruit, had a lackluster 2023 season at Penn State, struggling in key games. By lumping Howard into the same category, Zaire effectively downplayed Howard’s impact as Ohio State’s new QB.
The comment quickly went viral, with Ohio State fans defending Howard, while some critics agreed with Zaire’s assessment.
Who is Will Howard?
For those unfamiliar with Will Howard’s journey, his path to Ohio State has been one of resilience and constant improvement.
- High School & Early College
Howard was a three-star recruit coming out of high school and landed at Kansas State. While not highly touted, he quickly earned playing time due to injuries at the position. - Success at Kansas State
Howard eventually became Kansas State’s starting quarterback, leading them to a Big 12 Championship in 2022. During his time with the Wildcats, he developed into a tough, experienced leader known for his ability to make plays with both his arm and legs. - Transfer to Ohio State
Despite his success, Howard entered the transfer portal following the 2023 season, looking for a bigger stage to showcase his skills. Ohio State, needing a replacement for Kyle McCord, saw him as the perfect fit.
At 6’5” and 240 pounds, Howard brings size, experience, and mobility to Ohio State’s offense, making him a valuable addition to the Buckeyes’ roster.
Why Did Zaire Take a Shot at Howard?
There are several possible reasons why Malik Zaire made this comment:
1. Notre Dame vs. Ohio State Rivalry
As a former Notre Dame quarterback, Zaire might have a natural bias against Ohio State. The Fighting Irish and Buckeyes have had heated matchups in recent years, including Ohio State’s last-second win over Notre Dame in 2023.
2. Questioning Howard’s Ceiling
Zaire may genuinely believe that Howard isn’t an elite quarterback and that Ohio State fans are overhyping him. While Howard was solid at Kansas State, he has never been viewed as a top-tier talent like Caleb Williams or Drake Maye.
3. Clout and Social Media Engagement
Former players often make bold statements to gain engagement on social media. In today’s media landscape, controversial takes can generate clicks, retweets, and debates, keeping their name in the conversation.
Whatever Zaire’s motivation, his words have added an extra layer of pressure and motivation for Howard as he prepares for his first season with Ohio State.
Howard’s Response & Buckeye Nation’s Reaction
Will Howard has not publicly responded to Zaire’s comment, but Ohio State fans were quick to fire back. Many pointed out:
- Howard has more experience and better leadership skills than Allar.
- Howard has already won a conference championship, something Allar has yet to do.
- Ohio State’s offense will provide him with elite weapons to prove doubters wrong.
Some fans even believe that Zaire’s comment was an attempt to downplay Ohio State’s championship aspirations.
What This Means for Ohio State
1. More Motivation for Howard
Quarterbacks love proving critics wrong. Howard will have an extra chip on his shoulder heading into the 2024 season, knowing that some still doubt his abilities.
2. Ohio State’s QB Room is Stronger Than Ever
Howard isn’t just handed the starting job—he’ll have to earn it. The Buckeyes have Devin Brown and freshman Air Noland competing for snaps as well. If Howard wins the job, it means he’s truly the best option for Ohio State.
3. The Buckeyes Are in Win-Now Mode
Ohio State loaded up on talent in the transfer portal, with Howard at quarterback and elite playmakers around him. The pressure is on for the Buckeyes to win the Big Ten and make the College Football Playoff.
Final Thoughts: Will Howard’s Chance to Silence Critics
At the end of the day, Malik Zaire’s comment will only matter if Howard underperforms. If Howard thrives at Ohio State, leading them to a Big Ten title and a deep playoff run, he’ll have the last laugh.
But if he struggles, Zaire’s words will echo throughout the season, and the criticism will only grow louder.
For now, all eyes are on Will Howard as he prepares for the biggest challenge of his career. Will he rise to the occasion, or will his critics—including Zaire—be proven right? Only time will tell.
Leave a Reply