San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy has been at the center of heated debate regarding his contract negotiations. Reports indicate that Purdy could be in line for a $300 million deal, a number that has sparked controversy among analysts and fans. One of the loudest critics of this potential contract is Chris Simms, a former NFL quarterback and current NBC Sports analyst, who called the figure “insane.”
Simms is not alone in his skepticism. Many believe that while Purdy has been successful in San Francisco, he is a product of the 49ers’ system and supporting cast rather than an elite quarterback worthy of a record-breaking deal. This article explores the debate surrounding Purdy’s contract, why analysts believe he is overvalued, and what this means for the 49ers moving forward.
Brock Purdy’s Rise in the NFL
Purdy’s journey to becoming San Francisco’s starting quarterback is one of the most unlikely success stories in recent NFL history. As the last pick in the 2022 NFL Draft, he entered the league with minimal expectations and was labeled “Mr. Irrelevant.” However, injuries to Trey Lance and Jimmy Garoppolo thrust him into the starting role during his rookie season.
Despite his draft status, Purdy thrived in Kyle Shanahan’s offensive system, leading the 49ers to multiple wins and an appearance in the NFC Championship Game. He continued his success in 2023, further solidifying his place as the team’s franchise quarterback.
Purdy’s accuracy, decision-making, and poise under pressure have earned him praise, but critics argue that his success is heavily dependent on San Francisco’s elite roster and coaching staff.
Chris Simms’ Harsh Criticism of Purdy’s Contract Demands
Chris Simms has been one of the most vocal critics of Purdy’s rumored $300 million contract extension. During a recent segment, Simms made it clear that he does not believe Purdy is worth a deal of that magnitude.
“That’s insane. He’s not even close to being an underrated quarterback in the NFL. If you put him on a different team, we wouldn’t even be having this conversation,” Simms stated.
Simms argued that Purdy is a system quarterback, benefiting from an offensive scheme designed by Kyle Shanahan, as well as weapons like Christian McCaffrey, Deebo Samuel, George Kittle, and Brandon Aiyuk. He suggested that Purdy would struggle on a less talented roster and questioned whether he would even be a starting-caliber quarterback without the 49ers’ elite supporting cast.
Is Brock Purdy Really Worth $300 Million?
The biggest question surrounding this debate is whether Purdy has done enough to justify a $300 million contract extension. If signed, the deal would place him among the highest-paid quarterbacks in NFL history, alongside Patrick Mahomes, Joe Burrow, and Josh Allen.
Purdy’s 2023 stats were impressive:
- Completion percentage: 68.4%
- Passing yards: 4,280
- Touchdowns: 31
- Interceptions: 11
- Quarterback rating: 111.2 (led the NFL)
While these numbers are solid, Purdy still lacks the elite arm strength and mobility that define top-tier quarterbacks like Mahomes, Lamar Jackson, and Josh Allen. Many analysts believe he is being overvalued due to the team around him.
Simms compared Purdy to Baker Mayfield, who recently signed a contract worth $30 million per year with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Simms argued that Purdy is “not even close to as good as Baker Mayfield,” making a $300 million contract unjustifiable.
Why Purdy’s Contract Puts the 49ers in a Difficult Spot
San Francisco faces a challenging decision when it comes to Purdy’s contract extension. While they want to reward him for his performance, committing $300 million could negatively impact their ability to retain other star players.
- Salary Cap Limitations: A massive contract for Purdy would force the 49ers to make tough roster decisions, potentially losing key players like Brandon Aiyuk and Deebo Samuel.
- Better Options Available? Some believe the 49ers could find another quarterback to succeed in Shanahan’s system at a lower cost.
- Risk of Overpayment: If Purdy fails to elevate his play or regresses, San Francisco could be locked into an unfavorable deal for years.
Some within the organization argue that Purdy should take a team-friendly contract, allowing the 49ers to maintain their competitive roster. However, Purdy’s camp will likely push for market value, setting up a potential contract standoff.
The Role of Shanahan’s System in Purdy’s Success
One of the biggest arguments against giving Purdy a massive contract is that he isn’t the reason for the 49ers’ success—the system is.
Kyle Shanahan has a track record of making quarterbacks look great in his offense. Past examples include:
- Matt Ryan (2016 MVP season in Atlanta under Shanahan)
- Jimmy Garoppolo (Super Bowl appearance in 2019)
- Nick Mullens (solid performances despite being a backup)
With Shanahan’s play-calling, Purdy often has wide-open receivers, strong pass protection, and elite run support. This makes his job easier compared to quarterbacks who have to carry their teams without elite coaching and talent.
Many analysts argue that if Purdy were on a different team, he would not be in the MVP conversation or considered a top-tier quarterback. This is why Simms and others believe $300 million is too much for a player who may not be elite on his own.
Possible Outcomes for the 49ers and Purdy
San Francisco must decide whether to:
- Give Purdy the $300 million contract – This would secure him as their franchise QB but could hurt the team’s ability to build a deep roster.
- Negotiate a lower deal (around $30-$40 million per year) – This would be more team-friendly and allow them to retain other stars.
- Let Purdy test the market – If another team is willing to pay him $300 million, the 49ers could move on and find a cheaper replacement.
There is also a chance that Purdy himself is willing to take a pay cut to keep the team competitive. Some quarterbacks, like Tom Brady, have done this in the past to ensure long-term success.
Final Thoughts
Brock Purdy has been an incredible story in the NFL, going from Mr. Irrelevant to a franchise quarterback for the 49ers. However, whether he deserves a $300 million contract remains a heated debate.
Analysts like Chris Simms argue that Purdy is overrated, benefiting from an elite supporting cast and coaching staff. If he were on a different team, they believe he would not be considered among the league’s best quarterbacks.
San Francisco now faces a difficult decision. If they overpay Purdy, it could hurt the team’s salary cap and roster depth. If they let him go, they risk losing a quarterback who has already proven he can win in their system.
Only time will tell what the 49ers decide, but one thing is certain: the Brock Purdy contract situation will be one of the most talked-about stories in the NFL offseason.
Leave a Reply